Sensitivity and supplementary analyses

Main analysis → assumption perturbation or supplementary question → alternative analysis → comparison

Flow diagram

Sensitivity and supplementary analysesSensitivity and supplementary analysesF1.S1Main analysis and target estimandF1.S2Robustness or supplementaryquestion?F1.S3Sensitivity analysisF1.S4Supplementary analysisF1.S5Compare results on defined scalesF1.S6Interpret robustness andlimitationsF1.N1Analysis comparisonAnalysisEstimandChangedassumptionPopulationEstimateIntervalSourceMainSensitivitySupplementaryF1.N2Scenario rationale

Steps

Main analysis and target estimand

Identify the primary estimate and assumptions.

Robustness or supplementary question?

Distinguish the same estimand under alternative assumptions from a different scientific question.

Sensitivity analysis

Perturb assumptions while retaining the target estimand.

Supplementary analysis

State the different estimand, population or additional question.

Compare results on defined scales

Describe agreement and differences without treating all analyses as interchangeable.

Interpret robustness and limitations

Record implications for the original conclusion and remaining uncertainty.

Tables and supporting information

Analysis comparison

Analysis comparisonAnalysisEstimandChangedassumptionPopulationEstimateIntervalSourceMainSensitivitySupplementary

Keep the target estimand visible for each row.

Scenario rationale

Cite prespecified sensitivity plans and supporting methodological sources.

Sources